VACATION RENTAL INSURANCE: PROPER INSURANCE® REVIEWS

Proper Insurance takes pride in offering the most comprehensive short-term rental coverage on the market, paired with a claims experience policyholders continually rave about.

Consistently rated 5 stars, our policyholders describe a process that’s easy, stress-free, and straightforward — handled by real humans who are empathetic, thorough, and prompt. When something goes wrong, you can be confident you won’t be navigating it alone.

AirbnbClaimCoverageExperienceKnowledgeRentalService
Beth Gassel Avatar
I worked with Rikki to secure homeowners insurance on a 2nd home property and she was outstanding to work with. A good listener, never pushy, solutions oriented with excellent patience and follow-up skills. She was also very knowledgable about the short term rental market offering expertise and advice. I highly recommend her for anyone looking for insurance in a difficult insurance market.
Beth Gassel 1 week ago
Jonathan Blum Avatar
Proper Insurance is a new insurance option for our seasonal rental, in Mid-Coast Maine. So far, we have found its products are inventive, its service first rate and the pricing is reasonable. We look forward to a long relationship with the firm.
Jonathan Blum 1 week ago
Alex Starke Avatar
I have had an excellent experience with… I have had an excellent experience with Proper Insurance for the last four years and would highly recommend them to anyone who owns or operates a short-term rental property. And here’s the revised short review: I have had an excellent experience with Proper Insurance for the last four years and would highly recommend them to anyone who owns or operates a short-term rental property. As a short-term rental owner, I needed coverage that truly understood vacation rentals, not just a basic homeowners policy. Their team has always been professional, responsive, and clear in explaining the coverage. I feel much more confident knowing my property, guests, liability, and rental income are properly protected. I highly recommend Proper Insurance to any Airbnb, VRBO, or vacation rental owner looking for specialized coverage and real peace of mind.
Alex Starke 2 weeks ago
Jeff Melang Avatar
5-Star Review! 5-Star Review!! I recently filed a claim with Proper Insurance after a water heater caught fire in one of my short-term rental apartments. Cali Sawinski was an absolute pleasure to work with from day one. She was incredibly responsive, provided frequent updates, and made the entire claims process smooth and stress-free. Payment for the water heater was handled quickly and fairly, and she is still actively following up on the loss of business income portion. Proper Insurance has exceeded my expectations. Highly recommend — especially if you want a claims team that actually communicates and cares. Thank you, Cali!— Jeff Melang, Camel City Lofts
Jeff Melang 3 weeks ago
Christopher Polanco Avatar
Best Insurance Money Can Buy I have never written a review on an insurance company before but I cannot say enough good things about Proper Insurance. I had pipes freeze over winter that burst causing significant water damage throughout my cabin in upstate NY and Proper insurance helped me make the best of an absolute nightmare. Katee Gibson was my desk adjuster and was an absolute pleasure to work with. She was prompt, professional, quick to respond to all my inquiries and handled my claim process exceptionally well. You never expect anything to go wrong but when it does it makes a world of difference to have great insurance on your side. Proper Insurance came through for me with a generous and quick settlement of my claim for all damages and my home was made whole again. They even paid for my loss of business income. I cannot recommend them enough, thank you Katee and thank you Proper Insurance you guys are the best!
Christopher Polanco 3 weeks ago

Peace of Mind Delivered to Your Inbox

In an industry that keeps you busy enough, our monthly newsletter makes staying informed effortless. Get the latest on emerging trends, real short-term rental risks, and regulatory changes.

"*" indicates required fields