Airbnb Host Guarantee Fails to Reimburse Property Owner

Last year, Heather Harnell renovated her old condo and decided to list it up on Airbnb, a popular short-term rental platform. It was quickly rented out by October 1st and by the next day, utterly destroyed.

According to the report, the guest held a 60-person party that resulted in theft and significant property damage totaling about $14,000. With receipts and adequate video evidence in hand, Harnell contacted Airbnb to take advantage of the well-known Airbnb Host Guarantee, a coverage plan with $1,000,000 in protection, of which the company frequently boasts.

The Airbnb representative assured her of coverage and escalated her claim but before long, two months went by without any progress. While a claims adjuster apparently showed up to examine the damage later on, there’s been no word of whether what kind of reimbursement, if any, that Harnell received.

Airbnb has stated that claims involving significant property damage are rare, or about 1 in 41,000 bookings. But with so many news reports and horror stories involving stolen or damaged property, this number is clearly inaccurate.

A home destroyed by a fire.

Peace of Mind Delivered to Your Inbox

In an industry that keeps you busy enough, our monthly newsletter makes staying informed effortless. Get the latest on emerging trends, real short-term rental risks, and regulatory changes.

"*" indicates required fields

About the Author

Proper Insurance

Proper Insurance is the nation's leading short-term vacation rental insurance provider, with the most comprehensive policy on the market. We protect homes in all 50 states with unmatched coverage for your property, revenue, and business liability, customized to include guest-caused theft/damage, liquor liability, amenity liability (bikes, kayaks, hot tub, etc.), bed bugs, fleas, squatters, and more.

More
Resources

An illustrated Ohio short-term rental cabin lit at dusk in fall forest, with a hot tub on the deck and a path leading to the entrance.
September 21st, 2026

Can I Be an Airbnb Host in Ohio? What Hosts Should Know About the Ohio STR Landscape

A group of guests plays a board game outside of a loft apartment used as an Airbnb
September 21st, 2026

Understanding Rental Arbitrage: A Guide for 2026 Airbnb Arbitrage

New Airbnb hosts add property to booking platform.
September 14th, 2026

New Airbnb Hosts’ Safety & Insurance Guide for 2026

A vacation rental living room mid-restoration with drying fans and an opened ceiling from a burst pipe.
September 11th, 2026

What Happens to Your Short-Term Rental Income After a Claim?