Should You Allow Pets at Your Short-Term Rental? Pros and Cons of Pet-Friendly Airbnbs

Should You Allow Pets at Your Short‑Term Rental?

Allowing pets at your short‑term rental can increase bookings and nightly rates—but it also introduces serious liability risks many hosts don’t realize they’re exposed to. Animal‑related incidents like dog bites, property damage, and neighbor claims are among the most common and costly liability issues tied to vacation rentals. And this isn’t a far-fetched scenario. According to the Insurance Information Institute, more than 4.5 million people are bitten by dogs each year in the United States, most of them children, totaling billions of dollars in losses due to medical costs and legal settlements.

The Demand for Pet-Friendly Short-Term Rentals  

Pros of Allowing Pets at Your Vacation Rental 

Allowing pets at your short-term rental can be a powerful amenity for those deciding what vacation home to book for their family. Allowing pets at your vacation home provides many benefits to your short-term rental business like: 

• Widening your guest pool. Allowing pets can open your rental to an extra 70% of guests who own pets and don’t want to leave them behind. IntelliHost’s 2025 study found that allowing dogs can improve Airbnb platform visibility by 28%.
• Earning more revenue. As a short-term rental that allows pets, you have the option to charge a higher price or add a pet fee. 
• Attracting more responsible guests. Many hosts have reported that pet owners have been some of the most responsible guests that they have. They believe that pet owners already have the responsible trait of owning an animal and that they will respect your home. However, even the most responsible pet-owning guests can’t prevent every possibility of damage. Accidents do happen, especially when animals are involved.  
• Improving your reputation. It is highly likely that after their stay, a pet owner will recommend your property to others looking for pet-friendly options in the area. The guest might also leave you a tail-wagging review for making their furry family members welcome at your property.

Cons of Allowing Pets at Your Vacation Rental 

As the owner of the short-term rental business, you can be held responsible for the actions of your guest’s pets on your property and to your community, and you can even be held responsible for your neighbor’s pet’s actions to your guests. It could be argued that without your vacation rental home, the guest would not have been in the area, and therefore, the accident would not have happened. Here are some additional considerations for having a pet-friendly short-term rental: 

Flea Infestations Aren’t Rare in Vacation Rental Homes 

Another risk exposure for pet-friendly rentals is the potential of flea infestations. Fleas are tiny bloodsucking parasites that can hitch a ride from an animal and infest your vacation rental property, putting you at risk of lost revenue due to cancelled bookings and even expensive professional pest control treatments. Pet‑related liability exposure isn’t limited to bites, either—infestations like fleas brought in by guest pets can lead to cancelled stays, lost income, and remediation costs, which is why hosts should understand how flea coverage for short‑term rentals works.

Pet Damage at Short-Term Rentals

We all know that pets can cause damage, whether it’s destroying a screen door or tearing apart the couch, and now they could be doing it at your rental, a place they are unfamiliar with and likely anxious in. Most policies have exclusions in their policies that restrict coverage for ‘guest-caused damage’, which includes their pets. So, in the case of a guest’s dog damaging your home, a standard Homeowners or Landlord policy would not respond and would have you take it up with your guest. 

Barking and Noise Concerns for STRs

No one likes a barking dog in the middle of the night or during the day, especially the neighbors. You don’t want to receive a call from your angry neighbors, reporting that your guest’s dog is disrupting the neighborhood. These unwanted disruptions contribute to the further pushback against short-term rental properties in the market, resulting in more regulations and bans. 

Pets at Airbnbs Can Worsen Guests’ Allergies 

This might not be the first thing that comes to mind when allowing pets at your vacation rental, but it’s important to consider. Allowing pets could turn away guests who have allergies to pets. It’s important to consider that some have extreme reactions to pet dander, and while rare could result in serious health concerns for your guest and likely legal trouble for the owner if a pet was snuck onto the property by a previous guest. 

Your Insurance Might Not Cover Animal or Pet Incidents 

Dog bite incidents are among the most costly animal‑related liability claims in the United States. According to the Insurance Information Institute, Homeowners insurers reported 28,450 dog‑bite claims in 2025, totaling $1,862 million in losses, a 25.6% increase in claims from the prior year. The average cost per dog bite claim reached $65,450, nearly double the 2016 level, driven by rising medical costs and higher legal judgments.

Because of this, whether you choose to allow dogs at your short-term rental or not, it’s important to look at your insurance policy to see if you are covered for animal/pet liability. Not all policies, including Homeowners, Landlord, and Commercial policies, cover pet liabilities, and/or they may specifically exclude certain dog breeds, dogs with a history of biting, and exotic animals from coverage. 

Understand Exclusions in Standard Policies 

When you’re a landlord, you can verify the type of dog your renter has at your property. When you’re a homeowner, you understand the risks of your own dog and are knowledgeable about their breed. However, as a short-term rental property owner, you may not always take the extra steps to confirm the type of animal, breed, or bite history for every booking at your property. 

It’s also important to keep in mind that, depending on the severity of the bite, the cost of the claim could vary widely. If your policy does not include pet liability, it will likely be up to the short-term rental business owner to pay the legal fees and any settlement costs out of pocket. 

The Proper Insurance policy does not have exclusions for types of animals or dog breeds, and offers $1,000,000 per-occurrence of commercial liability with an option to upgrade to $2,000,000 if desired. In addition to the commercial liability limit you choose ($1M or $2M), Proper Insurance will also pay for the cost of defense lawyers. 

You Will Need Off-Premises Liability  

It’s also important to consider that if your guest’s dog bit your neighbor somewhere in the neighborhood, they were beyond your property line at the time. This is important because if you carry a landlord-type policy, your liability protection is most likely premises liability, meaning that it will only respond in cases where the incident happened ON your property. 

If an incident takes place beyond the property and you do not have off-premises liability coverage, unfortunately, the host would not be covered by their policy.  

Proper Insurance’s policy at its core is a Commercial Business Policy with Commercial General Liability coverage. This means that the coverage is not restricted to your property line, as it would be in a standard Homeowners or Landlord policy. Think of our policy as following your guests and their pets wherever they go while they’re staying at your vacation home.

Service Animals and Short-Term Rentals 

Legally, you are required to make accommodations for people with service animals. This means that a person with a service animal can rent a property that typically does not allow pets in their house rules. 

This is something that, as a short-term rental property owner, you should be aware of in case the situation ever arises. While service animals should be appropriately trained to perform tasks for the handler, accidents can still happen, and you’ll want to be prepared for them if they do.  

Airbnb and Vrbo provide hosts with specific guidance on dos and don’ts when it comes to service animals, emotional support animals, and therapy animals. Hosts should familiarize themselves with each booking platform’s terms of service on the topic.

You Decided to Allow Pets. Now What? 

After evaluating the pros and cons of allowing pets at your vacation rental, you’ve chosen to welcome man’s best friend to your property. After all, allowing pets can be a great way to set your property apart from others and can generate even more revenue for you as long as you have the right insurance coverage for the risks that allowing pets brings along. 

Here are a couple of things to keep in mind to reduce any pet liability issues at your rental: 

• Check with your HOA and local ordinances. There could be regulations regarding certain areas where pets aren’t allowed. It’s also important to outline these regulations within your short-term rental agreement. 
• Decide if you’d like to charge a pet deposit and if you’d like to refund it at the end of a stay or keep it. 
• Verify your insurance policy. Make sure that your policy does not have exclusions or limitations for pet liability or animal liability. If it has pet/animal liability, then you’ll want to make sure it does not limit or exclude certain breeds or animals. You’ll also want to make sure your liability limit is high enough to cover dog bites. Proper insurance recommends carrying a minimum of $1M in liability coverage. 

Considerations for Animal Liability: Wildlife 

If your vacation property is in a popular area for visits from wildlife, like a cabin located in bear country or a waterfront property near high alligator populations, it’s important to know if your policy has animal liability. 

Although you can’t control the wildlife around your rental, and you can’t control your guests on their vacation, you can take steps to prevent unwanted encounters between the two, like providing a wildlife safety document in your rental agreement and securing garbage cans and food sources. And while wildlife situations may be rare, they can certainly be dangerous and costly if they do happen. With Proper Insurance you don’t have to add yet another worry to your plate as a short-term rental host. Our comprehensive coverage includes animal liability, so no matter if it’s a bat, a bear, a bison, or a bully breed, know you’re covered.  

Upgrade Your Short-Term Rental Insurance Today 

If you are sued because of a pet or animal harming either a guest or neighbor, unlike most insurance companies, Proper does not have a limitation or exclusion. If you are found liable for an incident with an animal like a dog bite or a traumatizing bear scare at your short-term rental, Proper Insurance’s liability coverage would respond with: 

• Commercial Liability Coverage – Proper Insurance’s policy carries $1M per occurrence of commercial liability, with an option to upgrade your limit to $2M. This coverage extends off-premises, should your guest or their pet get injured or cause injury away from your property. 
• Legal Defense Cost – In addition to the limit you select as your liability coverage ($1M or $2M) Proper Insurance will cover the legal defense fees associated with the liability claim.  

Proper Insurance is the nation’s leading short-term vacation rental insurance provider, with the most comprehensive policy on the market. We protect homes in all 50 states with unmatched coverage for your property, revenue, and business liability, customized to include guest-caused theft/damage, liquor liability, amenity liability (bikes, kayaks, hot tub, etc.), bed bugs, squatters, and more. 

Give us a call at 888-631-6680 to receive a comprehensive coverage comparison, or submit a request for a 3-minute quote today. 

Pet Liability FAQs for Short‑Term Rental Hosts