Short-Term Rental Industry Highlights with Darren Pettyjohn – an Interview on The Invited Guest

The Team at Proper Insurance is happy to present an overview of a recent interview between Darren Pettyjohn, Co-Founder of Proper Insurance and host Scott on “The Invited Guest” by Private Porch.

Scott and Darren discuss why hosts should verify their short-term rental’s insurance, the response to COVID-19 from property management companies and customers, and staying positive – the short-term rental industry will recover from this unique time.

The invited guest interview with Darren Pettyjohn

Verify Your Insurance Coverage

Why is it important for hosts to verify their insurance coverage?

Hosts see two very different things sold for short-term rentals. Supplemental Host Protection sits on top of a homeowners or landlord policy—fine as a supplement, never a substitute. A short-term rental policy stands alone: it replaces the policy on the property, so one contract covers the rental business.

What are the Main Coverages Hosts Look For?

The main coverages hosts look for in a policy is for both fire and liability. If there were an accidental fire at the property resulting in total loss of the home, hosts want to ensure there is sufficient coverage in place to respond to the damage. For liability coverage, hosts are looking for coverage for the short-term rental exposure. Hosts are ultimately competing with Hilton and the same concerns apply, if a guest is injured at the property is there coverage in place?

Proper Insurance designed their full replacement, comprehensive insurance policy to fill the gaps in traditional insurance policies. With over 200,000 policies written, Proper is the nation’s leader in short-term rental insurance.

How is COVID-19 Affecting Property Managers?

Proper Insurance works with property managers across the US and has received mixed responses regarding the effects of COVID-19. A recent conversation with a property management company in Hill Country, TX revealed they are busier than ever. It seems that many guests are leaving the urban market and opting to stay in rural areas to wait out this season.

On the other hand, many property management companies are taking an honest look at how to keep their business afloat while preparing for pent up demands once people start traveling again.

What are Hosts’ Reactions Toward Their Listing Platforms?

There have been varying degrees of pushback from hosts toward their short-term rental platforms (Airbnb, Vrbo, bookings.com, etc.) Most of these platforms are middle men between the guest and the host, and on some level they can’t meet the needs of both parties equally. This season provides an incredible opportunity to build a new platform brand for short-term rental hosts. Getting back to a subscription model may be ideal, building a path that is best for the hosts. A subscription model would encourage hosts to expand their network to generate traffic, ultimately giving hosts a boost and growing the business overall.

Stay Positive: The Short-Term Rental Industry Will Recover

While it is difficult to see the light at the end of the tunnel, the team at Proper Insurance is confident that the short-term rental industry will regain speed soon. People will continue to go on vacations, and alternative accommodations will only increase in popularity as guests look for the comforts of home on the road.

Now is the time for hosts to review their coverage, make sure their properties are properly insured for business activity, and prepare for the pent up demands of guests ready to travel again soon.

Proper Insurance leads the nation in short-term rental insurance, with over 200,000 policies written in all 50 states. Backed by Lloyd’s of London and Concert Specialty Insurance Company, and exclusively endorsed by Vrbo, Proper Insurance is built on world-class insurance coverage that meets and exceeds both city and lender requirements.

Peace of Mind Delivered to Your Inbox

In an industry that keeps you busy enough, our monthly newsletter makes staying informed effortless. Get the latest on emerging trends, real short-term rental risks, and regulatory changes.

"*" indicates required fields

About the Author

Proper Insurance

Proper Insurance is the nation's leading short-term vacation rental insurance provider, with the most comprehensive policy on the market. We protect homes in all 50 states with coverage built for your property, your business income, and your business liability, customized to include guest-caused theft/damage, liquor liability, amenity liability (bikes, kayaks, hot tub, etc.), bed bugs, fleas, squatters, and more.

More
Resources

Covered cedar hot tub on a ground-level stone patio at a mountain cabin, with non-slip steps and a locking cover, illustrating Airbnb hot tub safety rules
November 12th, 2026

Hot Tub Rules & Safety for Your Airbnb: What Every Host Needs to Know

Airbnb host standing outside his short-term rental property, representing the liability exposure hosts face without a dedicated insurance policy
November 11th, 2026

Does Airbnb Provide Liability Insurance? What Every Host Needs to Know

Wooden lake dock with a kayak, rescue rope and buoy, and life jackets illustrating short-term rental amenity liability coverage
November 10th, 2026

Which Short-Term Rental Amenities Create the Most Liability Risk?

Close-up of a clipboard with a rental agreement and pen on a wooden desk in a sunlit entryway, with house keys in a ceramic bowl beside it, illustrating short-term rental liability waivers.
November 6th, 2026

Do Liability Waivers Truly Protect Short-Term Rental Hosts?