$11.6 Million Verdict Against Short-Term Rental Owner

Updated: September 7, 2023

Screenshot of a rental agreement liability waiver.

What Exactly Happened?

According to the complaint, an extremely inebriated short-term renter dove into a pool/lagoon which was 3 feet deep, broke his spine and is a quadriplegic. The plaintiff claimed the vacation rental owners knew the lagoon was shallow and unsafe for short-term rental guests and had failed to provide basic safety warnings.

However, the public record shows item # 13 in the host’s rental agreement indicating a waiver of liability and language referencing “Owners assume no responsibility” with regards to the pools, balconies, and stairs.

How Could The Owner Have Avoided This Verdict?

Without seeing all the evidence, we can’t speculate, but one thing is for sure, a rental agreement alone is not enough. At Proper, we insure thousands of short-term vacation rental owners that offer pools, and our underwriting is strict when it comes to pool safety standards required for this very reason. Therefore, we require the following:

  • Depth markers on all pools
  • A swim-at-own-risk sign posted
  • Life safety equipment in the pool area
  • A waiver of liability in the rental agreement in regard to the use of the pool

It might be too late for these Alabama homeowners, but it isn’t for you.

Verify Your Short-Term Rental Insurance Today

While it’s important to ensure that your vacation rental has adequate safety features provided, it’s impossible to know what could happen, and that’s why it’s also important to have a policy to protect you and your business if an incident like the above were to happen at your rental. Proper Insurance leads the Nation in short-term rental insurance, with over 100,000 policies written in all 50 states. Backed by Lloyd’s of London and exclusive endorsements from short-term rental leaders such as Vrbo, Proper Insurance is built on world-class insurance coverage that meets and exceeds both city and lender requirements.

Peace of Mind Delivered to Your Inbox

In an industry that keeps you busy enough, our monthly newsletter makes staying informed effortless. Get the latest on emerging trends, real short-term rental risks, and regulatory changes.

"*" indicates required fields

About the Author

Proper Insurance

Proper Insurance is the nation's leading short-term vacation rental insurance provider, with the most comprehensive policy on the market. We protect homes in all 50 states with unmatched coverage for your property, revenue, and business liability, customized to include guest-caused theft/damage, liquor liability, amenity liability (bikes, kayaks, hot tub, etc.), bed bugs, fleas, squatters, and more.

More
Resources

A small, single-family short-term rental house depicts tax write-offs for Airbnbs with dollar bills in the air and a calculator on the ground, drawn in a storybook illustration style with orange and blue hues.
December 31st, 2025

Maximizing Airbnb Tax Write-Offs: What You Can Deduct on a Vacation Rental Property

Airbnb with view of stadium during the 2026 World Cup
December 29th, 2025

Airbnb Hosting for the FIFA World Cup: Revenue Potential and City-Specific Rules

December 9th, 2025

The Homeowner’s Guide to Short-Term Renting for the 2026 FIFA World Cup

Snowy mountain resort with cozy cabins
November 21st, 2025

Do HOAs Allow Airbnb? What Hosts Should Know About CC&Rs