SHORT-TERM RENTAL INSURANCE RECOMMENDED BY KATIE FROM STR LAW
Katie Johnson is a real estate attorney and short-term rental host, and a graduate of the University of Michigan, with 15+ years of legal experience and over a decade of hands-on hosting.
She’s the founder of STR Law and co-owner of Mitten Rentals, which she runs alongside her husband, Matt. That combination is what sets her apart: legal advice built on real hosting experience, not just theory. It’s the same attention to detail that’s earned Mitten Rentals over 1,000 five-star reviews, and it’s what her clients rely on when the stakes are real, whether that’s a lease dispute, a licensing question, or a deal that needs to close correctly the first time.
Katie speaks regularly at leading industry events, including the Level Up Your Listing Summit, the Michigan Short-Term Rental Conference, and the Vacation Rental Management Association (VRMA), where she helps hosts and investors navigate an industry that’s evolving faster than the laws written for it. That’s the edge she brings to every client: a decade of proof behind every piece of advice.
Or Call 888-631-6680
Connect with a Short-Term Rental Insurance Expert
"*" indicates required fields
“The gap between ‘I think I’m protected’ and ‘I’m actually protected’ has never been more expensive. Every week I see hosts discover the gaps only after something goes wrong. A guest is injured and an insurance company denies a claim. That’s why it’s so important not to just have insurance, but to have the right insurance for short-term renting.”

– Katie Johnson, STR Law
What Makes a Proper Policy?
These fundamental coverages form the backbone of every Proper Insurance policy.

Commercial General Liability
Secure your STR business and gain peace of mind with robust Commercial General Liability protection, starting at $1M.

Exceptional Building and Contents Coverage
Protect your property and contents with replacement cost coverage, new for old, with no occupancy restrictions, so you’re covered even during vacancy.

Business Income Protection
Protect your rental income with Business Income coverage that pays your actual lost business income after a covered property loss, until repairs are complete or you reach the limit you chose.
60-Second Insights
Watch these quick videos to learn about short-term rental insurance essentials.
Leveraging Insurance to Your Benefit
The Proof is in Your Policy: Guest Caused Damage
Accidents Happen. Is this Host Liable for Guest Injury?
With Proper Insurance You Gain a Dedicated Risk Manager
Insurance is complex—especially when a property blends homeownership with an active, income-generating business like a short-term vacation rental. Proper’s expert agents don’t just quote coverage; they act as risk managers, trained to assess your property’s unique exposures, spot potential safety concerns, and guide you through underwriting and local regulations. It’s this combination of expert guidance and a purpose-built policy that provides real protection for your short-term rental.





Peace of Mind Delivered to Your Inbox
In an industry that keeps you busy enough, our monthly newsletter makes staying informed effortless. Get the latest on emerging trends, real short-term rental risks, and regulatory changes.
"*" indicates required fields
There When You Need Us Most
Short-term rental owners have seen it all and our clients are no exception. The ultimate peace of mind when hosting comes with a comprehensive policy that you can rely on.
Our claims testimonies are proof to why Proper Insurance is the most trusted short-term rental insurance provider from coverage through claims handling.
Follow Proper Insurance on Social Media
FAQs
Is a short-term rental considered a business?
Yes, short-term rentals are an income-generating business and can, therefore, be excluded from coverage in traditional home insurance due to business activity exclusions commonly found in those policies. Increasingly, more local jurisdictions and state-imposed regulations of short-term rentals like Airbnb and Vrbo are requiring property owners and hosts to register, purchase a business license, pay business occupancy tax, and carry commercial business liability.
Do I keep my Homeowners or Dwelling/Landlord policy in place and get the Proper Insurance policy?
No. The Proper policy fully replaces your current coverage. You can confidently cancel your current Homeowners or Landlord policy and replace it with the Proper Insurance policy. Proper Insurance offers the most comprehensive coverage available for your property, liability, and business revenue and is far superior to a standard Homeowners or Landlord/Dwelling policy.
If I have Airbnb’s free AirCover Host Damage Protection, why do I need short-term rental insurance?
Airbnb’s Aircover Damage Protection is more like a warranty program in which they will make you contact the guest for proof of what happened. If the guest says, “It wasn’t me,” and refuses to pay for the damage, etc., then Airbnb has the complete authority to decide whether to fulfill that claim on your behalf.
Airbnb’s Aircover Damage Protection explicitly states that it is not insurance, so you are not listed as insured on their protection. Unfortunately, many hosts have come to the hard realization after a claim at their short-term rental that they have no power with Airbnb’s Aircover.
Additionally, Airbnb’s Aircover does not extend off of their booking platform, so if you ever short-term rent directly or on Vrbo, Booking.com, etc. You won’t even have the supplemental hope of AirCover.
Can I be held liable for incidents or accidents off my property line that happen to my guests or because of my guests?
Yes, you can absolutely be held liable for the actions of your short-term rental guests. Like any business (think Walmart or Starbucks), you can get sued for injuries or accidents that involve your business (guests), whether they take place on your property or not.
This is because when you post your property as a short-term rental online, you are inviting these people into the community. This is especially true if your online listing also advertises your property as being a safe home and/or surrounding environment.
It could be as simple as a guest falling on the street getting out of an Uber in front of your short-term rental property or more complex like your guest assaulting your neighbor or a stray dog that attacks your guest. Commercial General Liability, which the Proper Policy carries, is built to respond to claims like these, on and off the property.
What can I expect during a risk assessment with Proper Insurance?
At Proper Insurance, we believe in the power of educating our clients. We understand that insurance can be confusing, especially for short-term rentals.
We want you to understand the details of the policy you currently have so you can decide if upgrading to the comprehensive coverage of Proper Insurance is right for your short-term rental business.
During a risk assessment, your Proper Insurance dedicated risk manager will walk through your current policy to help you decipher the coverage it provides for your short-term rental. Our agents are experts in short-term rental insurance and can outline gaps or exclusions in other policies that, at a minimum, the insured should be aware of.
Common gaps we see in traditional Homeowners or Landlord policies include limits on business activity, guest-caused damage, and amenities such as bikes, golf carts, and kayaks.
Latest
Resources
Can You Still Require a Rental Agreement Under Airbnb’s New Rules? Exceptions, State Laws, and Insurance
Cold-Season Success: Prepare Your Short-Term Rental for Winter
6 Ways to Prevent Legionnaires’ Disease in Short-Term Rental Hot Tubs
