Do You Know Who Is Staying in Your Vacation Rental?

If you’ve been listing your home on Airbnb, Vrbo, or Homeaway for any length of time, you’ve surely run into inquiries on your property that look completely bogus. Or maybe you just get the sense that something isn’t entirely on the up-and-up.

Perhaps they are asking you for your contact information because they want to circumvent the booking process, or, perhaps the language just seems like its boilerplate, or it was written by a bot. How do you know if you are doing business with a human who is truly interested in your property – with no ill intentions? Remember, it is your responsibility to vet potential guests. The booking website is simply a tool to introduce guests to hosts.

A living area features a couch and a chair

A Simple Internet Search Can Suffice

If the person’s name seems fishy, or anything else about the inquiry is raising a red flag for you, do some quick Googling to see what comes up. If it’s not a name like “Joe Smith,” you should hopefully be able to find a social media profile or some other evidence that the person asking about your short-term rental is legit.

The good (and sometimes bad) news is, a person’s reputation is starting to leave an online footprint. So, if your potential guest has a history of violating house rules or other infractions while staying in a rental property, chances are, someone has documented it online.

However, just because you don’t find anything online doesn’t mean nothing has ever occurred. This is where you have to trust your instincts.

Talk to Them on the Phone

Going “old school” and calling a potential short-term renter on the phone is another great way to take a quick pulse of the situation. If the phone call seems sketchy or if they start asking you for personal information, make sure you don’t reveal anything that could leave you vulnerable to a potential scammer.

Use an Online Tool to Help Verify Guests’ Identities

Look into tools such as SafelyStay.com, which can crosscheck a potential vacation renter’s name and other information given at the time of inquiry to quickly let you know that it’s safe to proceed with booking.

Sites usually are also able to validate if the person making the inquiry has been flagged as having previously been a “bad guest” at other vacation rentals; for example, if they have violated any rules or caused damages. Using a site like this can save you time from doing this digging yourself and may uncover information that a Google search couldn’t.

Have Faith in Your Guests

Most of the time, scams are easy to spot. And for the most part, people have good intentions when looking to rent from you. Awareness is key – as long as you are aware of the red flags to look for, then your experience with renting your vacation property should go smoothly.

Quote Your Short-Term Vacation Rental Today

Proper Insurance leads the nation in short-term rental insurance, with over 200,000 policies written in all 50 states. Backed by Lloyd’s of London and Concert Specialty Insurance Company, and exclusively endorsed by Vrbo, Proper Insurance is built on world-class insurance coverage that meets and exceeds both city and lender requirements.

Proper’s policy covers vacation homes, townhouses, condos, duplexes, cabins, cottages, apartments, and more. With expert vacation rental underwriters, we can tailor a policy specific to your short-term rental property.

Peace of Mind Delivered to Your Inbox

In an industry that keeps you busy enough, our monthly newsletter makes staying informed effortless. Get the latest on emerging trends, real short-term rental risks, and regulatory changes.

"*" indicates required fields

About the Author

Nick Massey

Nick Massey, the Chief Sales Officer at Proper Insurance, boasts over a decade of experience in the specialty insurance sector, with more than seven years dedicated to the company. His expertise lies in guiding short-term rental owners and property managers through the intricacies of vacation rental insurance. Known for his ability to clarify complex insurance matters, Nick enjoys connecting with clients, understanding their business stories, and sharing his insider insights to help them protect their investments and succeed in the competitive short-term rental market.

More
Resources

Sink full of dirty dishes, while children play outside in a swimming pool
November 17th, 2026

Can You Still Require a Rental Agreement Under Airbnb’s New Rules? Exceptions, State Laws, and Insurance

Family and golden retriever walking a snowy path toward a blue short-term rental home with a lit front porch, snow-covered evergreens, and mountains at sunset
November 16th, 2026

Cold-Season Success: Prepare Your Short-Term Rental for Winter

a man exhibits signs of legionnaires disease from a short-term rental hot tub, one cost of avoiding to effectively prevent legionnaires' disease in Airbnb hot tubs
November 13th, 2026

6 Ways to Prevent Legionnaires’ Disease in Short-Term Rental Hot Tubs

Covered cedar hot tub on a ground-level stone patio at a mountain cabin, with non-slip steps and a locking cover, illustrating Airbnb hot tub safety rules
November 12th, 2026

Hot Tub Rules & Safety for Your Airbnb: What Every Host Needs to Know